From: Min-Zhao Lee 2/11/99 21:15:44
Subject: Crystal Growth post id: 4418
In science discussion today we observed crystal growth, especially the effect of speed of formation (rapidly cooled solutions form many small crystals, slowly cooled ones form few large ones). We noticed that: the centre of the crystals looked like a mess, there was a water current moving from all directions to the crystal (there were suspended particles in the water that demonstrated this quite well), layers appeared in the crystals. It was conjectured that when cooled quickly, a large number of particles lost enough energy to become nuclei for crystals, and since there was only a certain amount of solute, each of the crystals was small. When cooled slowly, only some particles became nuclei at first, the rest were then formed into these crystals before they had a chance to form crystals themselves, and so there were few, but large, crystals. How correct is this theory?

From: Alan 2/11/99 21:51:40
Subject: re: Crystal Growth post id: 4435
Basically your on the right track. I know how all this works in metal crystals, I hope I can explain it correctly for salt crystals.

Rapid cooling force the crystals to solidify out of the liquid quickly. Basically they will form where ever they can nucleate.

With slower cooling you have the same number of nucleation points, but as the crystals the larger one will grow in prefence to the smaller ones as they attain a lower energy state. In fact the smaller ones over time will dissolve until a single crystal is present (this depends on the rate of cooling and how much ionic mobility can occur at the final temperature).

With the layering effect you observed, think about it in terms of the concentraction of ions in the solution. Before any crystals form you have a super saturated solution, as the temperature decreases the first cystals will form, these will contain the highest concentraction of the salt. As the temperature decrease the concentraction of the ions in solution has decreased, subsequent layers on the salt will contain more will be formed from a solution contain less ions and hence more water molecoles will be attached to the crystals.


From: kelvin fox 3/11/99 0:11:55
Subject: re: Crystal Growth post id: 4474
you are on the mark as far as i acn recall from uni lectures. We grew a number of crystals slowly and also quickly and looked at them growing under a microscope. The quick growing crystals apear feathery and form a felted mat. The only crystals that did not do this were cubic crystals such as salt. Basically if you grew them fast enough you could not pick the crystal symmetry or which crystal type it was (crystals form in one of seven groups). When formed slowly individual crystals of good symmetry were formed. try growing crystals of lead chromate slowly. They are hollow and form the most wonderful crystals.

Kelvin fox

This forum is un-moderated. The views and opinions expressed are those of the individual poster and not the ABC. The ABC reserves the right to remove offensive or inappropriate messages.